Jonathan Taylor, Ayanna Chapman, 9 Years Together

Two Salem High School players found love with one another when Jonathan Taylor, a running back for the Indianapolis Colts, fell in love with Ayanna Chapman, his High school sweetheart.  In addition to football, Chapman participated in field hockey, basketball, and track. She also went on to play field hockey together at Ball State.

Taylor, meanwhile, attended Wisconsin for football before joining the Colts as the 41st overall choice in the 2020 NFL Draft. The celebrity pair have been quite public about their romance, posting several sweet photographs and videos on their social media accounts. Taylor proposed to his longtime girlfriend in March of 2022.